Rakes Of Mallow: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Last Jannero Pargo Post Bar-right-arrows



Trying to Put 1-7 in Perspective Going Into The Bye Week

As we recap the first two-thirds of the Irish season this week, things will probably be very critical.  Obviously no one is happy about the current state of affairs, and any baby steps taken in a positive direction following the 38-0 loss to Michigan were taken right back in the 38-0 loss to Southern Cal.  We're like Gene Wilder walking down the stairs in Willy Wonka, but I don't feel like we're ever going to get to that delicious river of chocolate.

Still, before we lay into Charlie Weis, the "veteran leaders," and other members of the coaching staff, let's put a few things in perspective.

  1. Our offense could conceivably be the worst in the last decade and one of the worst of all-time.  seriously.  It's not good, people.
  2. Despite that rather disheartening fact and after an effort where you might find it hard to recruit a Notre Dame student to come to another Notre Dame game, Weis got a verbal from five-star ultra wide receiver Michael Floyd.  Rob, our recruiting guru here, was sure Saturday night we'd lose at least three players from the class that have already committed, and while it's still very possible we might, this is one positive sign and this is another that things might not totally collapse come signing day.  Hat tip to the Alumni guys on Madison for showing Floyd a good time on Friday night.
  3. We've played a ridiculously tough schedule to open the season.  As far as spurts go, it's nothing like the Florida-Kentucky-Auburn run that LSU just made it through or the upcoming slates for both Southern Cal and Arizona State as they enter the heart of the PAC-10 beast, but it was a rough haul.  We played eight teams, all of which will probably end up in bowls, and it's good for the second hardest schedule in the country behind Washington, according to Jeff Sagarin's ratings.   There's no excuse for how awful we've looked in most of these losses, but again, perspective.
  4. Other coaches struggle, too, although not nearly as badly as Weis has this season.  A few of note just from Saturday and just from the SEC:
  • Tommy Tuberville, who had won 9 of 10 games against the AP Top 10 and generally has Auburn in the range of a Top Ten team, managed the game during LSU's final possession as poorly as anyone could.  Holding onto a one-point with two timeouts, Tuberville ordered a squib kick, refused to challenge a horrendous spot on third and short then just hoped LSU would mismanage the clock instead of trying to reserve time for Brandon Cox to win the game if the Bayou Bengals did put a score up.  This strategy almost worked, because Les Miles, with the clock ticking under ten seconds, tossed up a deep fly route that left a lot of people befuddled.  If the ball is tipped or Flynn takes an extra second to get it away, time expires and they feed Miles to that friendly looking tiger that hangs around the Golden Girls.  Ballsy, yes.  Intelligent, not so much.
  • Steve Spurrier, who I think we can consider a certifiable offensive genius, managed his Gamecocks to six points against Vanderbilt.  If you went back to 1997 and told somebody in ten years, the Ol' Ball Coach would be held to six points by the Commodores, not even the most adamant Vandy fan or jealous SEC rival would have believed you.  His team also only mustered meager experts against a Georgia team that was later exposed by Rocky Top and a LSU team that looks less and less impregnable on defense as the season rolls on.
I'm not trying to condemn Tuberville, Spurrier or Miles (well, maybe Miles), but just to point out that if you're watching non-Notre Dame football on Saturday or NFL on Sundays, you see a lot of poor play from a number of teams that are supposed to be helmed by great coaches.  However, you also see players making tackles, playing with heart, picking up blitzers and identifying the ball when it's in the air, which is why Weis will be under some scrutiny as we look back on the awful season that has transpired so far.

0 recs | Comment 2 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

My thoughts are best expressed in a retrospective:
"I really feel like if we played [Penn State] in late November, it would be a toss-up"

and

"I did go so far as to confidently say

..a toss-up, and as stated above most eloquently, it only makes sense a team with a lot of young talent would close the gap on a mostly veteran team by the end of the season.  Apparently you're one of the more ignorant Penn State fans, as a lot of the Nittany supporters I talked to after the game stated how good they thought the Irish would be over the next couple years.  If they are to improve going into next season, one would also expect some minimal improvement going into November, while your quarterback will be, barring some sort of miracle injury for the program, Anthony Morelli.  I'll stand by the statement that if this game were played in November, neither the line or final score would be nearly as large.

by M1EK on Oct 23, 2007 4:16 PM EDT   0 recs

You did have the advantage of...
...dislodging your dead weight of a starting running back - which your coaches wouldn't do - by having him rape someone, which I didn't take into account.    I still think we've definitely showed improvement against Michigan State, Purdue, UCLA and BC, and should Notre Dame play Penn State at the tail end of this season, neither the line nor final margin would be as large as it was in Week Two.  I know you're on a three game win streak and feeling very good, but Wisconsin, Iowa and Indiana have combined to beat...Washington State?  Michigan State?  Akron?

Still, I wish you the best this Saturday night against tOSU for chaos' sake.

by CW on Oct 23, 2007 8:22 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Rakes, the home of the Notre Dame Fighting Irish on the award-winning SB Nation.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Mark_after_wedding_small
Mission Being Accomplished in Ireland
Img_5482__crop_2__small
Derrick Mayes has is own blog!
Small
What’s taking so long to name Steve Orsini as new AD?
Small
Zook's Challenge
Van_gough_the_siesta_small
Will Notre Dame make the first annual NIT baseball tournament?
Small
The Blind Side and the Bell Curve
Galagaship_small
Welcome to the new Rakes Of Mallow and SB Nation
Small
Hey Jeff! Does Lake Superior State Have a Basketball/Football Coach?
Small
Cutcliffe to Duke?
Small
Momentum

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

Shamrock_small CW

Brady_quinn_small Rob

ad

Site Meter