Raking The Muck: St. Michael Rises Again
A lot ofimportant stuff in regards to injuries in Coach Weis' Tuesday. First, the good:
- Michael Floyd is cleared to play for the Navy game (!!!!!). Floyd had 13 catches for 358 yards and five touchdowns before going down with a broken collarbone in the Michigan State game. With Golden Tate playing at the level he is, Jimmy is going to have a field day back there.
- Robbie Parris is also back after Taylor Mays' attempted homicide. It's nice to see college football writers across the country starting to realize that Mays isn't actually a top-tier safety in the Eric Berry/Earl Thomas/Kyle McCarthy-mold, but really just a head hunter who we all were led into thinking was good. I was guilty of it as much as anyone, but writers are redeeming themselves nicely in noticing this, although it'll be interesting to see if NFL scouts pick up on it. (Probably not.) Nice to see Parris back, especially since Robby Toma and Duval Kamara have got some reps in his absence. Receiving corps is looking particularly deep now.
And the not so good:
- Back-up quarterback and heir apparent to the throne whenever Jimmy leaves, Dayne Crist, is out 4-to-6 months with a torn ACL. He could be back for spring practice, but nothing is certain there. If you were on the Notre Dame message boards this week, you might have been as surprised as I was to find that A) Only Notre Dame players enter the draft early and B) Only Notre Dame players get injured. I should start selling "Hold me, I'm Irish" t-shirts on this site for all of the emo Fighting Irish fans, we'd make a killing.
- Trevor Robinson is doubtful for Navy, and Armando Allen is day-to-day. If I had my druthers, I'd try to limit their action against the Midshipmen and get everyone up to one hundred percent for the throwdown with Pitt next Saturday night.
The most important things from these bullets are obviously St. Michael's return and Crist's injury. The offense might almost be unstoppable with Floyd back, but sadly, getting a big fourth quarter lead will mean increased reps for Evan Sharpley, who won't be on the team next season. John Goodman will now be your emergency third string quarterback, so um, Wildcat anyone?
*
We'll get into a more extensive look at the team in the coming weeks, but I'm very worried about the Irish basketball team this season. Even though they are playing an embarrassingly awful non-conference schedule, the Big East is still really good and Scott Martin's injury was an absolute killer. Martin was the second most important player on the team after first-team preseason All-American Luke Harangody, as was going to fill in the Kurz/Ayers roll as big forward who could shoot perfectly. Now we have a team that goes seven deep and relies on three-point shooting, only there are about two shooters you'd feel comfortable with.
Oh, what is it that you're drinking there, Seth Davis? May I have a sip?
Maybe I'm overreacting to one practice, but this team was bigger, deeper and more talented than I anticipated. Clearly, the Irish do not have much margin for error, and they certainly cannot afford any more injuries. But they've got the best player in the league, if not the country, and that's not a bad place to start. Notre Dame might have a low ceiling, but it also has a pretty high floor. Write it down: The Gody is going back to the NCAA tournament.
During the course of the article, Davis praises everyone on the team for something and compares Tim Abromaitis to Matty Carroll. I obviously hope he's right, but I'm going to maintain some skepticism until we actually see it mesh on the floor. The first non-tomato can for the Irish is Northwestern on November 27. They'll then play either Saint Louis or Iowa State, with the only opportunity for a big non-conference win coming December 19, when the UCLA Bruins roll into town. The Big East slate isn't as tough as it was last year with UConn and Louisville twice, but it's still not going to be easy. I will leave you with my single favorite part of the story:
When Cleveland Cavaliers general manager Danny Ferry told Harangody that the Cavs considered former Louisville forward Earl Clark a better pro prospect, Harangody told him, "I have a f------ problem with that."
*
Staying over at SI.com, Stewart Mandel spends part of his mailbag advocating a plus-one plan. If you frame the plus-one as a natural step to getting to a playoff, then I can accept it. If you frame it as some sort of cure to the many ills of the collegiate football postseason, you're an idiot. Tell me, if we're using the "Mandel Plan," what do you do in years like 2002 or 2005, when you have two clear, undefeated teams at the top heading into the bowls? Or, even more fun, what about in years like 2007, when it's a giant clusterf*ck? Who would play in the plus-one game then? LSU vs. USC? Or Georgia? Or Kansas? Or West Virginia?
Mandel tacks this onto the bottom:
I'm sure I will now be deluged with 800 e-mails picking my proposal apart, but keep one thing in mind before you hit send: There's at least a glimmer of hope the Mandel Plan could become reality (the SEC and ACC are already open to a plus-one), whereas any larger playoff proposal -- no matter how many political action committees form to support it -- still has a 0.0 percent chance of getting adopted any time soon.
Great, so I'm supposed to be excited your shitty plan has a chance to come into reality? Awesome. Thanks for that caveat, Stewart.
*
In the latest College Football Is Going To Hell News, they just added the Dallas Bowl for New Year's Day 2011. What esteemed program will you see play on what used to be a holy day for college football? I'm glad you asked!
Jan. 1, 2011 -- Big Ten (No. 6 team) vs. Big 12 (No. 7 team)
Jan. 1, 2012 -- Big Ten (No. 6 team) vs. Conference USA team
Jan. 1, 2013 -- Big Ten (No. 6 team) vs. Big 12 (No. 7 team)
Jan. 1, 2014 -- Big Ten (No. 6 team) vs. Conference USA team
Can I set my Tivo now?! Gee golly, can't wait to see Purdue and and UTEP square off while I'm nursing a hangover. IS NOTHING SACRED TO YOU PEOPLE?!
0 recs |
7 comments
|
Comments
Should I be Worried?
Is anyone concerned about Navy? I am not at all. I figure it will be a slow game and we will score on 3/4 of our possessions in the first 3 quarters and then cruise in the 4th. They will probably score a couple TDs. I am thinking a final score of 34-17 with us getting two FGs.
In fact, I am so unconcerned that I am not going to watch this game life. I am not exactly sure what that has to do with my level of concern, but I will be recording them game and watching it Saturday night. I am both nervous and excited as I have never not watched a game live.
by djta on Nov 5, 2009 3:02 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
This ND team is not good enough
to be unconcerned with Navy, especially since ND’s defense has not dazzled anyone. Navy’s triple option attack always presents problems since teams do not practice against that style of offense much. ND should be able to score a lot of points, so the concern will be stopping Navy’s ground game and avoiding turnovers and special teams disasters.
I always turn to the sports section first. The sports page records people's accomplishments; the front page has nothing but man's failures.
~Earl Warren
by lookingdeadred on Nov 5, 2009 4:36 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
and avoiding 3 successful onside kicks.
This space for rent.
by averagegatsby on Nov 5, 2009 9:34 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Triple Option
While they haven’t face a triple option team, they have faced option teams this year, Michigan for instance. Unlike years past, a number of teams have used option attacks against ND. While the triple option is certainly a different beast, it does not require the abrupt change that it usually does. Additionally, our rush defense has improved every game. I am pretty sure we are going to explode defensively. They will only be able to keep it close if they mix it up and have some big pass plays like they did against Ohio St.
by djta on Nov 6, 2009 12:52 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Navy's triple option
is completely different from the spread option occasionally employed by UM or pretty much anyone else for that matter. Navy and Air Force use the triple option because teams have little experience defending against it, so the triple option gives the undermanned service academies a chance to compete against better teams.
I always turn to the sports section first. The sports page records people's accomplishments; the front page has nothing but man's failures.
~Earl Warren
by lookingdeadred on Nov 6, 2009 9:01 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I understand that
But most years ND doesn’t play any option teams. While, as I stated, the triple option is certainly different than the spread option, they are more similar than a pro-style offense. Doesn’t really matter though.
by djta on Nov 6, 2009 11:24 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
[When Cleveland Cavaliers general manager Danny Ferry told Harangody that the Cavs considered former Louisville forward Earl Clark a better pro prospect, Harangody told him, “I have a f——— problem with that.”]
Clark is damn good. He’s NBA ready and should be getting more playing time than he has on this current Suns road trip (he played a lot more at home). Freakin’ Alando Tucker has played over him against the Heat and Magic.
But I agree, I have a fucking problem with anyone saying Clark is a better pro prospect. Harangody is gonna tear some stuff up in the NBA. Whoever drafts him is going to have fun winning.
Of course coming from Cleveland, let’s be serious. They were gifted James for sucking ball and they’ve completely failed at putting guys around him that can help out.
*
And hey, if Mays is a head hunter he won’t last long in the NFL, whatever scouts think. That just doesn’t carry a guy through 10 years, especially when the reputation is there. He’s gonna find his head is the one on the spit very soon.
I bet the Navy/ND game is closer than anyone thinks. I hope I’m wrong, too, and that Notre Dame wins by 20 like they probably should. But Red is right, we’ve got no business being unconcerned with this game. They could beat us. They might beat us. We might win 45-0. It’s the type of game where you’ve got to watch to see what happens.
Let’s not underachieve in this game. Navy plays us good enough every year that the 600 game winning streak against them lies. A few key mistakes on our part and Navy can pull this off.
Fanaticism is not logical
by SunDolphin on Nov 6, 2009 10:40 AM EST reply actions 0 recs

by 









